Authority - Whom do you trust?

At the heart of the Reformation, one finds shifting authorities. With this in mind, a quick overview of religious authority is useful. In the simplest sense, authority connotes trust and dependability. Authorities have two key attributes—validity and reliability. A valid authority is authentic—it demonstrates it is what it represents itself to be. A reliable authority remains trustworthy and consistent over time. A religious authority is a valid and reliable connection between humans and the Divine.

Religious authorities generate focus, reverence, and expectations. Authorities have not always been as they are today. While vestiges of former authorities persist, each generation contributes to the whole—each leaving a legacy for the next. Probably the most elusive authority is Scriptural (New Testament Canon) authority because under one term we find two significant distinctions—the authority of Scripture versus the authority of the translator or reader. Thus, one may believe Scripture is authoritative without believing specific translations or interpretations are authoritative. The authority of the Roman Catholic Church Fathers is another case entirely. Unfortunately, for most modern Protestants, the possibility of spiritual authority among the Church Fathers from 100 A.D.-1500 remains an unasked question.

The following religions authorities are evident in a variety of cultures and religions.

Natural authority: Authority from the perception of the Divine in nature. Few natural religions remain. Scientific authority: Authority from empirically verifiable evidence of the Divine.

Revelation authority: Authority from personal encounters with God followed by covenants defining conditions of relationship. The revelations of Abraham, Moses, Old Testament prophets, Christ, and Apostles are largely accepted among Christians. The revelations of David Koresh, Jim Jones, L. Ron Hubbard, and Sun Myong Moon are less accepted. Apostolic authority: Authority from those who knew Christ and were his disciples. The Apostles were the sources of the Gospels and letters to churches.

Tradition authority: Authority from traditions passed on from one generation to the next. Traditions are passed on through celebrations, ceremonies, and stories. Church Fathers: The disciples of the Apostles—authority from traditions established by the Apostles and their spiritual descendants—the emerging church (95-325 A.D.). Various writings attributed to the Apostles were considered authoritative, but an official canon did not emerge until 1549 at the Council of Trent.

Institutional authority: Authority from leaders or priests as covenant responsibilities shift from individuals to representatives. Covenants are codified, orthodoxy defined, and forms established. Council and denominational authority: Leaders or representatives define orthodoxy for the membership. The New Testament Canon and Sacraments of the Roman Catholic Church were established by the Council of Trent.

Divine (incarnation) authority: Authority by example: Jesus Christ—God Among Us. Jesus illuminates the Old Testament, initiating a reformation of Judaism while revealing the Kingdom of God through metaphors, similes, and analogies. Jesus Christ was God demonstrating “The Way”.

Personal authority (Reformation): Individual priesthood. Technology (printing press) and the emergence of an educated middle-class of freemen ushered in the Age of Reason—the authority of the individual and the masses. Personal abdication or disbelief: Authority does not exist.

Scriptural authority. Scriptural authority, as understood by most Protestants, is a relatively new phenomenon. The writings included in the New Testament were considered authoritative before they were canonized. However, personal access was severely limited until the advent of the printing press and education of the masses—beginning about 500 years ago. Scripture, depending on one’s point of view, may derive authority from one, all, or none of the previously mentioned authorities.

Which of these describes your experiences?

The Apostle's Church

I grew up in a church that disliked creeds. Creeds were considered an imposition on personal faith and priesthood of the believer. Good Baptists didn't recite creeds, liturgical prayers, or rote confessions. The prevailing paradigm: "The Bible says it. I believe it. That settles it." In our weaker moments we sanctioned responsive readings. I grew up a true Protestant--questioning all tradition and religious authority apart from the Bible.


I don't believe that way so much anymore. As I began to look into the origin of the Apostle's Creed, I became more and more convinced there was something I was missing. Rather than being words that bind one to a church or denomination, the Creed reminds one of the foundation blocks of the early church.


Charter Members

• Apostles: Peter and Andrew, James and John sons of Zebedee/Clopas (Jesus' cousins), Philip, Nathaniel, Matthew, Thomas, James son of Alphaeus, Thaddeus, Simon "the Zealot", Matthias; Justus (runner-up; lost the toss to Matthias)
• Deacons: Stephen, Philip the Evangelist, Prochorus, Nicanor, Timon, Parmenas, and Nicholas
• Jesus' Family: James, Judas, Joses, Mary, sisters
• Jesus' Relatives: Salome/Mary, wife of Zebedee/Clopas (Mary's sister), John Mark and Barnabas (Jesus' nephews)
• Others disciples: Joseph of Arimathea, Nicodemus, Mary Magdalene, Joanna, and Suzanna, Cleopas, bishop of Jerusalem, Ananias, who baptized Paul, and was bishop of Damascus, Prochorus, bishop of Nicomedia, Nicanor,  Timon, bishop of Bostra, Parmenas, bishop of Soli, Nicolaus, bishop of Samaria, Silas, bishop of Corinth, Silvanus, bishop of Thessalonica, Crisces (Crescens), bishop of Carchedon in Gaul, Epænetus, bishop of Carthage, Andronicus, bishop of Pannonia, Amplias, bishop of Odyssus, Urban, bishop of Macedonia, Stachys, bishop of Byzantium, Phygellus, bishop of Ephesus,  Hermogenes, Demas, who became a priest of idols, Apelles, bishop of Smyrna, Aristobulus, bishop of Britain, Narcissus, bishop of Athens, Herodion, bishop of Tarsus, Agabus the prophet, Rufus, bishop of Thebes, Asyncritus, bishop of Hyrcania, Phlegon, bishop of Marathon, Hermes, bishop of Dalmatia, Patrobulus, bishop of Puteoli, Hermas, bishop of Philippi, Linus, bishop of Rome, Caius, bishop of Ephesus, Philologus, bishop of Sinope, Olympus and Rhodion (martyred in Rome), Lucius, bishop of Laodicea in Syria, Jason, bishop of Tarsus, Sosipater, bishop of Iconium, Tertius, bishop of Iconium, Erastus, bishop of Panellas, Quartus, bishop of Berytus, Apollo, bishop of Cæsarea, Sosthenes, bishop of Colophonia, Tychicus, bishop of Colophonia, Epaphroditus, bishop of Andriace, Cæsar, bishop of Dyrrachium, Artemas, bishop of Lystra, Clement, bishop of Sardinia, Onesiphorus, bishop of Corone, Tychicus, bishop of Chalcedon, Carpus, bishop of Berytus in Thrace, Evodus, bishop of Antioch, Aristarchus, bishop of Apamea, Zenas, bishop of Diospolis, Aristarchus, Pudes, and Trophimus, who was martyred along with Paul. (according to Hippolytus of Rome)

Similar versions of the Apostle's Creed could be found around the Mediterranean within a century of Christ's ministry. Folk tradition attributes the twelve parts of the creed to the twelve apostles in Jerusalem. One thing is certain, first generation churches around the Mediterranean used creeds to keep in step with the first church established in Jerusalem by Peter, James, and John. The church was dispersed through persecution. As members of the first church left Jerusalem and began new churches, they took the Creed with them. Creeds were a confessional statement of agreement with the first church. Essentially, the Creed defined orthodox faith and served as a guard against heresy.


In the Council of Nicaea in 325, church leaders (overseers/bishops) from around the known world met and compared their various creeds.  Amazingly, the creeds in use in Italy, France, Africa, and Asia Minor were similar--suggesting a common source. As the church in Jerusalem sent forth Paul, Barnabas, Silas, Timothy, and others, and was eventually dispersed, one of two things happened. Either those who left took and imitated the practices of the Jerusalem church, or the apostles purposefully developed a "church starting kit" that included a faith statement for use in the new church.
What I have come to appreciate in the Apostle's Creed is it's nearness to the church immediately after Christ's ascension. I believe the Creed is very close to what Peter would have stated if I asked him to share his faith. The first church started with approximately 130 people who lived day-to-day with Jesus. The congregation included not only the Disciples, but the three Marys, Stephen, Barnabas, Timothy, John Mark, and others--a literal Hall of Fame group.


I find myself drawn to this first church and questions arise as I compare what can be seen in the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches--those related to Jerusalem started in Antioch, Ephesus, Rome, Thessalonica, and churches around the Mediterranean Sea.


Rightly or wrongly, the church experienced a quantum shift in 1550s when faith in overseers and traditions passed to faith in the Bible as interpreted by the individual. I hope replacing a relational faith and practice with textual faith and practice wasn't a mistake.